Dan Locksmith | Auto, Residential & Commercial Locksmith Services Skip to content

Broken Key? What To Do Next

A quick, safe checklist to remove a snapped key and prevent lock damage. TX & PA: Full service • NJ: Key duplication only.

Keys How-To Home • Car • Office
Broken key stuck in door lock

Do This First (Step-by-Step)

1

Stop turning or pulling on the key

Forcing it can push the broken blade deeper or bend pins inside the lock, turning a quick fix into a full replacement.

2

Align the keyway

Make sure the keyhole’s slot is perfectly vertical (or the same angle the key was inserted). Misalignment traps the broken piece.

3

Gently extract what you can see

Use tweezers or a thin paper clip on the visible edge. Avoid superglue tricks—glue can ruin cylinders and void warranties.

4

Lubricate sparingly

Spray a small amount of graphite or a dry Teflon lube into the keyway. Avoid oils—they collect dust and gum up pins.

5

If no luck in 2–3 minutes, stop

Pausing here prevents damage. We can extract the blade and provide a working key quickly.

Pro tip: Keep the other half of the key. It helps us cut a precise replacement (or decode a restricted profile).

When To Call a Pro

  • Broken piece is flush or recessed inside the keyway
  • High-security cylinders (Mul-T-Lock, ASSA, Medeco)
  • Car ignition/door with immobilizer or smart fob systems
  • Rental, commercial, or multi-tenant property locks
  • No movement after light lube and gentle attempt

TX & PA Full extraction, rekey, repair, and replacement.

NJ Key duplication only (we can make you a new key from the code or sample).

(802) 225-0502

Prevent It Next Time

Replace worn keys early

If a key looks thin or twists easily, get a duplicate from a fresh cut code before it snaps.

Lubricate cylinders annually

Use dry graphite/Teflon, especially on high-use doors and vehicle ignitions.

FAQ

We don’t recommend it. Glue spreads into the lock and binds pins/springs—often turning a simple extraction into a cylinder replacement.

Stop attempting to start the vehicle. We can extract the blade and cut/program a replacement in TX & PA. In NJ, we can duplicate keys (bring the original half if you have it).

Usually no—simple extractions don’t damage the lock. If the keyway or pins are bent, we’ll advise a repair or rekey.